Oyster Stew

Get ready, boos; this is my all-time favorite Oyster Stew recipe! The base is so rich and velvety, and the flavors from buttery sautéed onions and celery make it the perfect cozy-up dish for any chilly evening. I know some of y’all might be a bit wary of oysters, but believe me, this stew’s rich, creamy broth and tender oysters will convert even the staunchest skeptics!

This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure policy.

This simple oyster stew recipe is a family gem! I was a bit picky when it came to oysters; I dodged them like they were hot potatoes – but I’d be first in line for the broth. Nowadays, I love all things seafood, including oysters (especially when they’re fresh and briny!), but if you’re on the fence about them, this stew might just change your mind. It’s got an amazing, creamy, rich flavor that’ll have you coming back for more boos!

The Heart & Soul Of Oyster Stew

Cuisine Inspiration: Southern American
Primary Cooking Method: Simmering
Dietary Info: Pescatarian
Key Flavor: Rich and creamy seafood with a hint of garlic
Skill Level: Beginner

Sweet Spots

• Super Easy to Make: Y’all, this oyster stew is as easy as ABC. Even if you’re kinda new to the kitchen, you’ll whip this up in less than 20 minutes with no fuss
• Unbeatable Texture and Flavor: The stew strikes the perfect balance between a creamy, velvety texture and the briny, savory flavor of oysters. And that’s exactly why I always ask for seconds!
• A Cozy Comfort on Cold Days: There’s something about this stew that just warms you from the inside out. On those chilly nights, a bowl of this hearty, comforting stew is just what you need to feel cozy.
• Versatile and Adaptable: My favorite part about this oyster stew recipe? You can tweak it to make it just right for you. Not big on spice? Tone down the cayenne. Garlic fan? Add an extra clove or two. It’s a forgiving recipe that lets you play around and put your own spin on it.

Ingredients To Make Oyster Stew

• Unsalted Butter: Lets you control the saltiness while adding a rich, creamy base.
• Yellow Onion & Celery: They bring a subtle, savory depth to the stew, laying down a foundation of flavor that’s just right – not too overpowering, but definitely noticeable.
• Garlic: A little bit of this pungent, aromatic wonder goes a long way in adding that “oomph” to our stew. It’s a must!
• Celery Salt, Black Pepper, and Cayenne Pepper: Celery salt brings its unique earthy flavor, black pepper adds a mild heat and depth, and cayenne pepper gives that gentle kick. Together, they’re the ultimate flavor bomb for this recipe.
• All-Purpose Flour: Makes sure the stew has that perfect, slightly thickened texture without being too heavy.
• Half and Half: The real MVP for creaminess – nobody likes a watery homemade oyster stew! Half and half turns it into a creamy, dreamy delight.
• Fresh Raw Oysters in Brine: The stars of the show! These little gems bring the sea right into your kitchen, adding a briny, fresh flavor that’s just irresistible. Fresh is always best, but if you only have canned oysters, you can use them as well. If you want to know how to replace them properly, scroll down to the FAQ section!
• Worcestershire Sauce: This is the secret weapon of depth and umami. Just a touch of Worcestershire sauce and the stew gains a complex, slightly tangy flavor that makes you go, “Hmm, what’s that?” in a good way.
• Minced Chives: Chives are the classic garnish for oyster stew. They add a mild, oniony bite and a pop of color.

How To Make Oyster Stew

Get ready to roll up your sleeves and dive into making this mouth-watering southern oyster stew! And guess what? It’s so simple. I’ve got it all wrapped up in just 6 easy steps. P.S.: For those of you who like to keep an eye on the clock, all the exact cooking times are down in the recipe card!

1. Melt butter in a saucepan over medium heat. Add onion, celery, and garlic and cook until translucent.
2. Add in celery salt, black pepper, and cayenne, and cook for a few seconds.
3. Sprinkle in flour and cook for a minute.
4. Slowly stream in half and half, stirring vigorously to ensure a smooth paste. Once all the half and half has been added, bring to a gentle simmer and continue cooking, stirring occasionally. Do not let it come to a boil, as the milk will curdle.
5. Add in oysters and their brine and cook until the thin edges of the oysters start to ruffle.
6. Stir in Worcestershire sauce and taste for seasoning. Finish with chives and serve immediately with crusty bread or oyster crackers.

Tips For Making The Best Southern Oyster Stew

1. Mind the Simmer, Skip the Boil: Keep an eye on your stew and make sure it never reaches a full boil. If it does, you might end up with curdled milk – and nobody wants that. A gentle simmer is all you need!
2. Use the Oyster Brine: Don’t even think about tossing out that oyster brine! It’s packed with flavor and adds that extra hint of the sea to your stew. Straining it away would be a total waste.
3. Don’t Scrape the Bottom of the Pan: If you find your oyster stew sticking to the bottom of the pan, don’t panic. Simply pour the stew into another pan, leaving the burned part behind. This way, you keep all the good stuff and none of the scorched bits.
4. Slowly add the Flour and Half and Half: Take your time when adding the flour and half and half. Rushing might leave you with lumps. A slow, steady sprinkle of flour and a gradual pour of the liquid will give you that silky, smooth texture.

Popular Substitutions & Additions

• Bring on the Heat with Hot Sauce: For those who like a little extra heat, a few dashes of hot sauce, like Tabasco, can really jazz up your stew. It adds a kick that’s just right – not too overpowering, but enough to wake up those taste buds.
• Swap Half and Half for Whole Milk: If you’re out of half and half, go for whole milk instead of lower-fat options. Whole milk is less likely to curdle, ensuring your stew stays smooth and creamy, just like it should.
• Add Oyster Crackers: Nothing beats the satisfying crunch of oyster crackers in this creamy stew. Scatter a handful over your bowl and enjoy the delightful texture they bring!
• Mix In Diced Potatoes: For an even heartier oyster stew, consider adding diced potatoes. They’ll cook up to be tender and creamy, making the stew more hearty and comforting – perfect for those extra chilly nights.
• Sprinkle Bacon Bits: A sprinkle of cooked, crumbled bacon? Yes, please! It adds a smoky, savory twist that just sings with the flavors of the oysters and cream.

What To Serve With This Oyster Stew Recipe

• Seafood Delights: Pair it with a light shrimp scampi or crab cakes to keep with the seafood theme. It’s like having a little seaside shindig right at your dining table!
• Sides: Scoop up every last drop of that stew with some warm cornbread or a few buttermilk biscuits.
• Comfort Classics: If you’re going all out, why not serve it alongside some Southern fried chicken or a slice of savory meatloaf? These hearty classics are just the ticket for a comforting, soul-satisfying meal.
• For the Veggie Lovers: A side of Southern green beans or honey glazed carrots can add a sweet and savory note that complements the briny richness of the oyster stew beautifully.

How To Store & Reheat Oyster Stew

Got leftovers? Lucky you! Just let your oyster stew cool down to room temperature, then pour it into an airtight container. Slip it into the fridge, and you’re all set.

When you’re ready to enjoy your stew again, just reheat it gently over a low to medium heat. Stir it occasionally to keep the cream from separating and to ensure it heats evenly.

How Long Will Oyster Stew Last In The Fridge?

This tasty stew will keep well in the fridge for about 2-3 days, as long as you store it properly.

Can I Freeze Homemade Oyster Stew?

While freezing creamy stews can be a bit tricky due to the milk base, you can freeze this stew if needed. Just be sure to use a freezer-safe airtight container. It should stay fresh for up to 2 months in the freezer. Just remember, when you thaw and reheat it, the texture might change a bit, but it’ll still be delicious.

Frequently Asked Questions

Whether you’re an oyster lover or still sittin’ on the fence about ’em, this Oyster Stew recipe is worth a try. It’s simple, straightforward, and downright scrumptious. Plus, it’s a tribute to my Big Mama, who could whip up this stew like no one else. That’s how you know it’s real good!

More Seafood Stew Recipes

• The BEST Authentic Frogmore Stew (Low Country Boil Recipe)
• Moqueca Recipe (Brazilian Fish Stew)
• Best Seafood Gumbo Recipe
• Cajun Clam Chowder
• Shrimp And Corn Chowder

*Did you make this recipe? Please give it a star rating and leave comments below!* Post a photo of how your version of the recipe came out on Instagram (using #grandbabycakes)!!