Kentucky Butter Cake Recipe

Y’all, this Southern Kentucky Butter Cake Recipe is in a league of its own – it’s not your average butter cake, honey! I’ve jazzed it up with a twist of that nutty, rich browned butter flavor and topped it off with a sweet sugar glaze that just soaks right into every delicious inch. The texture? We’re talking moist and tender on the inside, with that sugar glaze hardening up just a bit to give you a little crunchy surprise on the outside. It’s like a little piece of cake heaven that’s just out of this world!

This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure policy.

As most of you know, pound cakes made in my Big Mama’s kitchen are highlights of my childhood. We belly laughed while mixing batters and licking spatulas we used to scrape bowls until they were sparkling clean.

Those memories mean everything to me, and the recipes we use are ones I still make on a regular basis. Today, I’m sharing one of my favorite cake recipes with a small twist that is sure to wow: A Kentucky Butter Cake Recipe.

The Heart & Soul Of This Kentucky Butter Cake

Cuisine Inspiration: Southern American

Primary Cooking Method: Oven

Dietary Info: Vegetarian

Key Flavor: Kentucky butter cake is rich and buttery with hints of nuttiness from the browned butter in both the cake and the sweet glaze. The cake is beyond moist on the inside with a crackly, buttery crust on the outside.

Skill Level: Beginner-Intermediate

Sweet Spots

• Perfect Buttery Flavor. Each bite of this cake is rich with butter! But it’s not just plain old butter, it’s browned butter so it has that extra richness and nuttiness from cooking the butter that infuses the cake and the glaze.
• All-Occasion Cake. This cake is a classic! Its simple, yet exquisite flavor, is perfect for all types of occasions from a dinner party dessert to a cake to carry for a potluck or brunch, and so much more!
• Great to Make Ahead. If you need a cake that’s even better the next day this cake is it! It actually even tastes better on the second day.
• Simple Ingredients. You don’t need anything more than basic ingredients when making this rich browned butter cake. You may have some of them in your kitchen and if not, they’re all easy to grab at the grocery store.
• Versatile Cake. It tastes amazing served up just as it is but also pairs well with a variety of different toppings and additions to create a dessert that will receive rave reviews!

What is Kentucky Butter Cake?

Butter cakes originated from the English pound cake, which traditionally used equal parts butter, flour, sugar, and eggs to bake a heavy, rich cake. Over time both butter-based cakes and pound cakes have become quintessential cakes in Southern American baking. My household saw more than its fair share of these cakes but Kentucky Butter Cake was a popular one.

Ingredients to Make Kentucky Butter Cake

• Unsalted Butter: We’re talkin’ rich, creamy, and ready to make this cake and glaze pop! Brownin’ the butter gives it a nutty, toasty vibe that’s simply amazing.
• Shortening or Oil: This is our secret weapon for added moisture.
• Granulated Sugar: Sweetness galore because that’s how we roll! It’s used to sweeten the cake and the glaze.
• Large Eggs: Room temperature, please! They mix in better and make our cake oh-so-fabulous.
• Sifted Cake Flour: The finest of flours for the most tender crumb.
• Salt: Just a pinch to balance the sweet.
• Baking Powder & Baking Soda: These guys are liftin’ us up and making sure our cake is on point.
• Buttermilk: Bringing in a bit of tang and tenderness.
• Vanilla Extract: Because every great cake needs a splash of vanilla goodness. You will also need a bit more to add that sweet, sweet vanilla magic to the glaze as well.
• Water: Just a splash to get our glaze to the right consistency.

How to Make Kentucky Butter Cake

Step 1: Mixing the Cake Batter

1. It all starts with completely cooled browned butter. I like to do this the day before because it takes a while to cool down all the way.
2. Add the browned butter and shortening. Beat them for two minutes at high speed.
3. Add the sugar slowly to the bowl and beat on high speed until the mixture is very pale yellow and fluffy.
4. Add your eggs in one at a time, making sure to scrape the sides as needed to fully incorporate them.

5. Add the flour and mix into the butter, sugar, and egg mixture using the lowest speed.
6. Pour in your buttermilk and vanilla extract.
7. Mix just until everything is combined. Be sure not to over-mix your batter!
8. Pour the cake batter into a prepared cake pan.

Step 2: Make the Butter Glaze

While your cake is baking, you’ve gotta make that sweet brown butter glaze that is going to take your cake from good to unbelievable. It comes together simply and with ease.

1. Melt the butter in a skillet.
2. Continue to cook until it’s browned and then remove from the heat.
3. Add the sugar, water, and vanilla.
4. Whisk together until the sugar dissolves.

Step 3: Assemble the Cake

1. Cool the cake in the pan for 10 minutes and then invert it onto a platter.
2. Poke several holes all over your cake using a wooden skewer.
3. Pour the glaze all over the cake so it seeps in and distributes all through the cake.
4. Dust with powdered sugar and serve it up!

Tips for Making the Best Brown Butter Cake

1. Watch the Butter Closely. You want it to brown and not burn so it’s a good idea to stay close to the pan while it’s cooking. The butter will first melt and then begin to foam a bit as it cooks. Then you will start to see browned flakes appear on the bottom of the pan. Cook until it’s an amber color and then remove it from the heat.
2. Cooled Browned Butter. The cooling process can take a few hours so I suggest making your butter the night before. Even if that is not possible for you, I can’t stress enough that your butter needs to be completely cool. Using brown butter that is still warm will change the texture of the cake. You’ll end up with a dense, not fully risen, and eventually hardened cake that won’t last through dinner.
3. Do Not Over Mix. This is THE key to tender cakes! Mixing too much causes the gluten to activate more which leads to a more dense texture.
4. Make to Poke Holes Over the Whole Cake. The holes will allow the glaze to thoroughly seep into the cake so make sure you cover the entire thing so it soaks into the cake evenly.
5. Cool the Cake in the Pan for a Bit. This makes it much easier to remove the cake from the pan while keeping it intact.

Popular Substitutions & Additions

• No Cake Flour? It’s important to use cake flour to keep this cake from developing too much gluten so don’t try to swap it for all-purpose flour. If you don’t have any you can make your own cake flour using flour and cornstarch.
• Rum or Bourbon Flavor. Add a bit of rum extract or liquor, bourbon, brandy, or any other extract flavor you enjoy to the butter glaze!
• Salted Butter. I prefer unsalted butter because you have more control over the amount of salt. However, you can use salted butter to make your cake but you might want to cut back or reduce the amount of salt you add to the cake. It may make the butter sauce poured over the top a bit saltier than the unsalted butter.
• Add Nuts. Stir in chopped pecans or walnuts into your cake batter just before baking.
• Buttermilk Substitute. If you don’t have any buttermilk on hand use regular milk instead combined with an acid. Add a tablespoon of vinegar or lemon juice to a measuring cup and then add milk to the one cup measure. Let it sit for five minutes.

What to Serve with Brown Butter Pound Cake

• While it tastes great all on its own, it’s even better with some fresh sliced fruit and whipped cream.
• Add a scoop of ice cream! It’s great with any flavor but you can’t go wrong with vanilla ice cream though strawberry ice cream is great too! You can even warm up the cake when serving with ice cream.
• Add a spoonful of homemade fresh berry sauce over the top!
• Add a dollop of lemon curd or another flavor of this tart creamy fruit custard.

How to Store Kentucky Butter Cake

Y’all keep this note: This browned butter cake gets even better as it sits so it actually tastes the bomb on the second day. Here’s how you can store it so it stays super fresh! Cool the cake completely and then wrap it in plastic wrap. Keep it at room temperature but someplace that’s cool and out of the sunlight.

If you want to serve it up warmed (so bomb!) you can heat individual slices in the microwave for a few seconds.

How long will Kentucky butter cake last?

When stored properly it will last at room temperature for up to four days. You can extend its freshness by keeping it in the fridge for up to a week however the refrigerator may dry out cakes.

Can I freeze browned butter cake?

Yep fo sho. Wrap it in plastic wrap followed by aluminum foil. Store it in the freezer for up to three months. Thaw it out in the refrigerator overnight and then let it sit at room temperature a bit before serving it.

Frequently Asked Questions

This Kentucky Butter Cake is not just another buttery dessert – it’s a whole mood! It’s got this extra little nutty oomph from browned butter and a sweet sugar glaze that just elevates it to superstar status. You better believe it’s gonna be the talk of the town at your next get-together.

More Brown Butter Dessert Recipes

• Ginger Browned Butter Blondies
• Butterfinger Browned Butter Cookies
• Browned Butter Maple Blondies
• Chai Brown Butter Snickerdoodles
• Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
• Pumpkin Bundt Cake